Thursday, July 21, 2011

We All Want What We Can't Have

            I'll be honest in saying that I don't know what this story is about or why in the world Louise Erdrich decided to write a story revolving around skunks. Perhaps my urban/suburban upbringing hinders me from truly grasping the longing for nature Erdrich rambled about for seven complete pages or perhaps I'm just trapped in a summer-induced lethargy, but either way, this story was beyond me. One portion of the story that did pique my interest, however, was the part about obstacles and desire.
            I guess I never realized how true the old saying "we want what we can't have" really is until I read this story. Everything Erdrich (or at least her character in this story) does is driven by some sort of unobtainable desire. Some sort of desire such as a job opportunity that was unobtainable in North Dakota must have driven her to leave her hometown and go to New Hampshire, but then as soon as she was 1500 miles away, she longed for everything she used to have. Her homesick desire drives her to find comfort in the woods of New Hampshire, and for a while, she was content. As soon as she came across the fence, however, she was no longer content. She had to get to the other side and feel the bark of the pines, not just look at them from afar.
           Many people would see this want-what-you-can't-have type of motivation as a negative thing. We use it to describe ignorant children more often than not, but it is prevalent in all our lives. Yesterday, I was watching How I Met Your Mother on TV, and in that episode, there was a perfect example of this attitude. Two of the main characters , Ted and Barney, are both ex's of another main character named Robin. Both had gotten over their relationships with her until she found a new boyfriend. Suddenly, they both realized they still had feelings for her and that they wanted her back. It was only when she became unavailable that they realized this. I realize that TV may not be the best source for an intellectual point, but this sort of stuff does happen even in small day-to-day occurrences that we don't even think about. It's perfectly natural, and I don't think it always has to be a bad thing.
           We remember people for the challenges or obstacles they have overcome. If everyone was content with what they had, no changes would be made, and the world would not be what it is today. Slaves desired freedom, which at the time seemed impossible, but through a long history of resistance against obstacles of persecution, they improved their lives significantly. This is prevalent in the story as well. In her dream Erdrich  describes the fence as impermeable, but once the desire to go beyond the fence sets in, she describes the fence as permeable, and she easily passes through.

4 comments:

  1. I think that she brought out the idea of desire and I really liked her idea of seeing the fence as impermeable and impossible to get passed, but once she saw it as permeable, it took some times, but she found a way to pass through it. I think this is true in our own lives. Until we truly believe that we can get past an obstacle in our lives, we will not be able to move on to the desire we wish to claim. The she describes man's foolishness over-thinking an obstacle into believing it unstoppable. In contrast to the skunk whose arrogance and foolishness allows it to take on any challenge without a thought. She challenges us to try this rash, yet direct approach to the obstacles in our own lives and never think it impermeable.

    ReplyDelete
  2. People are known for what they have accomplished, but they are truly remembered for what they did for others. I believe Skunk Dreams had more themes than met the eye and that both you and Kevin bring up good points from the story.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with Matthew about this. I think that this story had a variety of insightful themes throughout the reading. Personally, I believe that I found the story to be based off of what Tim had mentioned in his blog, but that's only because that's what I got out of the story. Although as soon as I read Kevin's post, he really had me thinking back to this story. It's completely true that we make our own obstacles seem impossible, and once we open our eyes and see things as possible, it only takes a matter of time from there.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I like what everyone's said here so far. As I read the story...whenever that was...I had the same types of thoughts flooding to my brain. At first, I was definitely confused, but I eventually put things together and figured out what it meant to me. I definitely agree with everyone's view on the story. Also, Kevin really managed to sum up almost exactly what I had been trying to put into words myself.

    ReplyDelete